Lens-Artists Challenge #70 – Monochrome
“War is what happens when language fails.”
Margaret Atwood
Last week, while hosting my brother and his girlfriend, we made a visit to nearby Fort Sumter, where the first shots of the U.S. Civil War were fired. The solemnity of the monument created a perfect opportunity for my response to Patti’s monochrome challenge.
“Listen up. There’s no war that will end all wars.”
Haruki Murakami
While historians disagree on some of the causes, it is clear that slavery was a primary issue dividing the country. Ironically, the bricks of the fort were fired and its walls built by slaves – some bricks still house their fingerprints. Further, along with the Confederate soldiers, slaves fought in the fort’s defense during the Union onslaught. Imagine the stories these walls could tell.
“Never think that war, no matter how necessary, nor how justified, is not a crime.”
Ernest Hemingway
Because Fort Sumter protected the only entry to Charleston harbor (through which the south’s war supplies were delivered), it was attacked mercilessly. After a failed attack by sea, Union troops assaulted by land, reducing the fort mostly to rubble. Despite heavy damage Confederate troops refused to surrender. After 20 months of attack by land and sea, Union forces abandoned the effort and sent their men and ammunition to assist in the campaign against Richmond, Virginia. The Confederates finally evacuated the fort in February of 1865.
“We will not learn how to live together in peace by killing each other’s children.”
Jimmy Carter
Sounds valiant, doesn’t it – after all, everyone loves an underdog. In reality though, the Civil War was friend vs friend, brother vs brother, neighbor vs neighbor. There is no winner in such a war, perhaps not in any war. 150+ years after its end, it’s only in the recent past that we have begun to address the horror of slavery and the injustice of discrimination.
“There are perhaps many causes worth dying for, but to me, certainly, there are none worth killing for.”
Albert Dietrich
The partially restored fort is now a National Monument managed by the National Park Service. The only access is by boat via the one company allowed to dock there. There is a history museum at the point of departure and a park ranger on the boat as well as at the fort. There are tours at the site as well as a free, open-air lesson on the fort’s history.
“All war is a symptom of man’s failure as a thinking animal.”
John Steinbeck
The boat ride to the fort crosses Charleston Harbor, typically populated by large ships awaiting access, small fishing vessels and small sailboats. Gulls and pelicans soar overhead and dolphins can be seen along the way. For $23 visitors enjoy a 30 minute cruise each way, access to the museum, and an hour to meander through the fort with guides well-versed in its history. There are no restrictions on photography.
“The world is full enough of hurts and mischances without wars to multiply them.”
J.R.R. Tolkien
As shown in my opening image, on the day of our visit the fort’s flag was flying at half-mast in honor of Senator Elijah Cummings’ passing. How ironic that 150 years after those within Sumter’s walls fought to defend slavery, a black senator was being honored by its flag. No matter our politics, this was a moment to savor.
Many thanks to those who responded to my “Seeing Double” challenge. The variety of responses was wonderful; we enjoyed every one of them. Patti, Ann-Christine, Amy and I greatly appreciate your support and look forward to your Monochrome responses. To view and link to Patti’s original post, click here. And please remember to tag your post with our Lens-Artists tag.
Hi Tina. I adore your new masthead art, the muted colors are gorgeous. Here’s my submission for this challenge
https://babsjeheron.wordpress.com/2019/11/16/beautiful-great-blue-heron-number-25-black-and-white/
Best, Babsje
Thanks for joining us Babsje!
>
Pingback: Beautiful Great Blue Heron Number 25 Black and White | Babsje Heron
Hi, Tina. I imagine that at Fort Sumter the US flag is always at half-mast. As a non-American interested in your nation’s history, this is a site I’d like very much to visit.
Actually, I’d have thought so too Henry, but it isn’t. Glad you found this one interesting
Perfect timing for Remembrance Day, Tina. Without mercy and forgiveness, war is always around the corner. Always enjoy your shots and narrative. Lest we forget 🌺
Thanks Perpetua – very well said.
What a wonderful and purposeful combination of images, prose, and quotes!
Thanks very much Laura, glad these struck a chord
Sent from my iPhone
>
It did! Inspires me as a creative and educator too! A multi-genre project maybe…
Sepia is such a wonderful choice for your subject matter.
Thanks Amy, I enjoyed playing with the NIK software for these
Photos from historical places are so perfect for black and white! GREAT entry Tina!
I agree Marie – so many of this week’s entries are historical in nature. Appreciate your visit and comment.
Pingback: Lens-Artist-PC-70-Monochrome – WoollyMuses
Your quotes and the irony of the Cummings honor are telling. The sepia tone in your images and the subject brings to mind the work of Matthew Brady. They look as they could have been captured in that time. “The camera is the eye of history.” – Matthew Brady
A sublime compliment John. Many thanks
Sent from my iPhone
>
Thank you for the moving history lesson to go with your exceptional photo choices. You’re right, they are great objects for monochrome. I love the pop of color in the last one, nice touch!!
Many thanks Shelley, especially for the nod to my final image, which took some interesting post-processing effort 😊
Sent from my iPhone
>
I love the sailboat peaking through the archway. Superb, Tina!!!
The cannons reminded me of the famous El Morro on the island of Puerto Rico.
I suppose all forts are created in the same way.
Izzy 😎
Thanks Izzy. That one took some work in post so appreciate your commenting on it
Sent from my iPhone
>
The opening quote you chose just sums it all up. The monochrome shade seems so fitting, almost like the photos had been taken back then. Thanks for the history lesson and info about Fort Sumter as well! Nice positive color scene in the last photo.
Thanks very much OLU, much appreciated. I did love that quote also.
>
You’re welcome.
Love the irony in your concluding paragraph. I would love the bat ride and freedom to roam photographically especially if my well versed guide is called Tina Schell!
I would probably love a bat ride even more … boat ride
LOL Abrie, a bat ride might be just the thing for people like you and me 🙂
>
Wonderful images, quotes and commentary Tina!
Thanks very much Michael, glad these caught your eye.
I particularly like how you have kept the sepia soft – gives the impression of faded photos so suitable for historical subjects
Thanks so much Laura. that was the goal so your comment was especially appreciated.
>
Wow!
Such places do take us back in time somehow and made us wonder in so many ways 🙂
Thanks Hammad, that was my goal. Much appreciated
Beautiful images Tina. You’re right, removing the colour adds to the solemnity of the place and gives age and authenticity to the photographs. I love the contrast you’ve achieved in the last photo, like looking out of the past into today.
Thanks so much Wendy, especially for your comment on the final image, I loved that
Fort Sumter is a great place to connect to the theme this week – I like how you
Opened with the flag shot –
And then all these quotes on war…. hmmm
Much to
Ponder
Thanks Yvette – a bit serious for me today. Glad you appreciated this one.
Appreciate them all …. as you know 😉
Your choice of processing gives most images a vintage patina.
Thanks Sally – that was indeed the goal
spectacular shots Tina….love all of the detail in each one…and the history lesson!!! ‘Sailing by’ is quite outstanding!!
Thanks April – that one did take some work 🙂
>
I liked the textures of the bricks you captured in your third shot. I also appreciated your thoughts on Representative Cummings. He was a great man.
Thanks Siobhan, he was indeed. I thought the flag at half-mast was particularly touching based on the history of the fort.
>
Beautiful historic photos!
Thank you Tatiana
Tina, these are wonderful images, and the quotes so apropos. I especially like the sailboat through the window (of course!) and the Jimmy Carter quote – so true.
Thanks so much Lindy. I enjoyed Patti’s “extra credit” on that one 😊
An excellent selection of monochromes, Tina! And an interesting subject that lends itself well to the monochrome treatment. Sometimes you need to get away from the distraction of color in order to focus on what’s really important, the story behind the pictures.
Well said Sue, glad you appreciated this one
Powerful images of a time in our history that forever changed America. Love your monochromes, Tina.
Thanks so much Terri, glad this one struck a chord
What a moving and powerful set of quotes (plus imagery!).
I don’t know much about the Civil War. Reading your piece really allowed me to frame it against current events.
Thank you so much for the history lesson/ meditation.
War is never simple. Divisiveness is so destructive.
Many thanks. Interesting that so many commented re not knowing much about the war. Such a major event in our history here in the U.S.
What a perfect post for me to discover a week before I leave for Charleston! I love the history lesson and the sobering quotes about war. How interesting that the flag was flying at half-mast in honor of Elijah Cummings. What a great idea to do this in monochrome. 🙂
Many thanks, happy for the good timing! Thought of you when I posted this one 😊
Great! It gave me inspiration for my trip. 🙂
I love how you managed to photograph history in a vintage way that lets it appear historic.
Great works, Tina.
Thanks so much Rabirius, I thought the monochrome with a touch of antiquing suited the subject
Yes, indeed it does.
I love monochrome photos, Tina! The last one is my favourite
Thanks Aletta, I love monochrome also, but then I love color too 😊
You are right! I do too
These photos of the fort are stunning in black and white. We must have been on the same wave length yesterday because I was thinking about using some of my civil war fort photos!
Thanks Beth, it’s the perfect subject for the week I think!
Very deep thoughts on war and man! Yes, war happens when language files, but then that happens because of the inability of humans to think humanly.
Great monochromes for the week, I feel the forts and history perfectly go well with monochromes! Probably because we watched too many B&W historical movies? The new generation may not see this. 😀
Thanks Raj – interesting thought about the historical films. Hopefully the older, especially historically accurate ones will live on
😀 That’s a nice way to put that Tina! 😀 I hope so too!
Excellence in monochrome …informative and vivid closeups…the camera lens sees more Thank you for the amazing information so to say..’in black and white’ best regards Tina Ji
My pleasure AWD – an interesting challenge this week I think
Yes Tina Ji a difficult one…will need to look for images in the treasure box…writing tasks leave me very little time this week but will try
I love the way you interpreted the theme, Tina. A beautifully expressed and beautifully photographed post on the tragedy of war. I am hoping that we (as a nation) have learned these lessons about civil war, but I fear we haven’t. The quotes really resonate with me.
Thanks Patti, I thought it was a good match for your excellent challenge theme. As for learning our lessons, sadly I agree with you
It is a pity that, despite history, we continue to make the same terrible mistakes.
In Spain we also had our civil war, my parents suffered it, which left us a dictatorship. Impressive photos to remember. Great post!
Thanks so much Ana. We do tend to know our own history better than others’ but I do remember reading about Spain’s Civil War. One wonders why we keep repeating the same mistakes 😢
Very informative, insightful, and thought-provoking post. Likewise the cogent quotes. Love the monochromes too. Fifty shades of grey.
A serious compliment from someone so well-read and we’ll-informed John. Thanks very much
Thank YOU.
Pingback: (The) Clouds Race Across The Sky – Proscenium
Rather than looking to the past, I looked here to the near future … reflected in a palette of colors …turned monochrome …
https://naamayehuda.com/2019/11/02/moody-monochrome/
Na’ama
Terrific, thanks for joining us Na’ama
🙂 Thanks, Tina!
Pingback: Moody Monochrome | Na'ama Yehuda
The monochrome fits with the subject, Tina
Thanks Sue, I thought so too.
😊😊
A wonderfully thoughtful and thought provoking post, Tina. The quotes are as apt as they could possibly be, and monotone is the only possible way to illustrate them. 🙂 🙂
Many thanks Jo – I agree the story lends itself to monotone. Your thoughts on this one are much appreciated.
The monochrome seems to capture the mood perfectly TIna. When will we ever learn that no one wins with wars of any kind.
Thanks MM – when indeed 😢
Impressive
Thank you Victoria
Such a powerful post, both in words and photos. It is well ended with Senator Elijah Cummings’s passing and was being honored by its flag. Yes “this was a moment to savor.”
Thank you for the post, Tina.
Many thanks Amy – I did think it made a real statement.
A richly reflective post…. thank you
Thanks Linda – rather a somber story but worthy of a small nod to history
Love the view of the sailboat and water in color! Gives life and hope to a rather dismal place…
Thanks Laurel – glad you spotted that 🙂
A piece of history well told, Tina. Both through images and words – as you say, a perfect choice for this challenge! And to us Europeans it meant a history lesson on a war we do not know much about. Love that you set sails too and let the vessel come through the thick walls!
Thanks so much A-C. Glad you caught my little twist on the sailboat too 🙂
Perfect
Beautiful picture sis. Awesome. Thank all for sharing.
My pleasure Flo – thanks for the motivation!
Your mono’s rock!! I would mind seeing you do more of them!
That is of course ‘not’ mind
I was hoping 🙂
Haha, you can not stop it that easy!! 😂😂
Thanks Chris. I don’t do them often but I do love them.
What an interesting post, I really enjoyed looking through your wonderful pictures and being reminded of this part of history!
Thanks Sylvia. I’m sure you’ve been out there. I think it’s the best bargain in town!